Officer
  • Honoring The Fallen
  • Publications
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Forums
  • Contact Us
  • Vehicles & Fleet
  • Tactical
  • Training & Careers
  • On The Street
  • Investigations
  • Command/HQ
  • Technology
  • Virtual Academy
  • Stations
  • Podcasts
  • Product Guide
  • Topics
    Vehicles & FleetTacticalTraining & CareersOn The StreetInvestigationsCommand/HQTechnologyProduct Guide
    Resources
    ForumsProduct GuideHonoring The FallenBy ContributorsExpert InsightsPublicationsWhitepapersWebinarsOriginal ContentJobs
    User Tools
    SubscribeAdvertiseContact UsPrivacy PolicyTerms & Conditions
    https://www.facebook.com/officercom
    https://www.linkedin.com/company/officer-com
    https://twitter.com/officercom
    1. Home

    Monday Morning Quarterbacking

    March 30, 2009
    Lt. Frank Borelli (ret), Editorial Director

    Frank Borelli
    Editor-in-Chief
    Officer.com

    This past week one of the most televised news stories, most discussed news reports, and most blogged about "news" events, was the traffic stop of an NFL player for running a red light. Like everyone else who has commented, for good or bad, on the incident, I have my opinion too. Unlike some of those who have commented, I've actually spent a career in law enforcement. Unlike some others, I refuse to pass judgment based on edited video clips and reporter OPINION - because I wasn't there; didn't see, hear and experience everything that officer did; and I don't have HIS life experiences to develop my decisions based on. In an effort to be objective there is one BIG point I believe needs to be made and then a collection of questions that should be asked. In some cases I will offer my opinion on what the answer is or should be. The Critical Point: If there hadn't been a player from the NFL driving that car, this never would have been national news. If that driver had been Joe Average Citizen, the mainstream media would never have picked it up and made such a big deal out of it. That irks me. The piling on of uninformed criticism that this officer has endured would not have occurred if this ONE person hadn't been an NFL player. I think it is unacceptable beyond expression that people all across this great country of ours have criticized a man who puts his life on the line for the community he serves every day in support of a man who gets paid far too much to play a GAME. That said, what are the questions that are pertinent and require answers? First and foremost in my mind: Did the officer do anything that violated any of his General Orders? If so, then proper remedial action needs to be taken. If not, then it needs to be announced: everything he did was in compliance with the agency's General Orders. The next question would also be about departmental controls. Did the officer violate any standing Standard Operating Procedures? If so, then proper remedial action needs to be taken. If not, then it needs to be announced. The last semi-objective question is: did the officer act unprofessionally? Yes, this is semi-objective. If you put twenty cops in a room and showed them the WHOLE video taped incident and asked them if the officer acted professionally or not, you'd likely get four or five different variations of "Yes" and "No". IF the officer acted unprofessionally then his actions fall back into the realm of his agency's guidance, disciplinary policies, etc. Beyond the objective "measurable" performance of the officer is the human factor performance. Was the officer too lenient? Did he show too much compassion? Did he not show enough? Was he unreasonable once he learned the circumstances at the hospital? I know officers who believe that showing any compassion at all compromises professionalism and shows weakness. I know other officers who believe that the very nature of police work is compassionate since we sacrifice so much so often to help total strangers. Truth be told, whatever compassion we carry around with us - as a part of who we are - is going to be displayed to some extent when we work. We can no more turn it off than we can the love for our families or our need for food. But that level of compassion is different for virtually every cop - so no two cops are going to agree on what the right amount of "understanding" is to show. Law limits it. In some states officers have discretion over whether or not they arrest for most misdemeanor crimes. Some crimes have mandatory arrest conditions (domestic violence is like this every where I know of). The amount of discretion an officer exercises is directly based on two things: the circumstances as he perceives them and his level of compassion in that given situation. To the incident at hand: I think it could have been handled differently based on what I've seen in the heavily edited and editorialized video clips. By the same token, I don't feel that the driver's violations of traffic law were justified by the family emergency. Is that cold to say? Maybe. Think about it though: if having a family member in the hospital - dying or otherwise - is an excuse to break the law, then why have the laws in the first place? I believe I would have approached this much as the officer did - and I can understand why the officer's adrenaline would have been pumping after this chase that finally ended in a parking lot with the driver and passengers jumping out of the car. Yeah... dangerous moment. It would not have been pleasant. BUT, once I had ascertained that there actually WAS a dying family member in the hospital, I would have asked the driver to give me his driver's license and then go tend ot his family business. That way I'd have had time to calm down; think about the whole situation start to finish; perhaps consult with a more senior or experience officer on his opinion about it. I'm sure there was a way compassion and enforcement could have mixed to perform my duties without having generated such a blast of criticism nationwide. But again... I still say this never would have been news if it had been Joe Citizen. Don't delude yourself: that cop is "under the gun" because the driver was an NFL player. Anybody else and the incident never would have been heard about outside Dallas. What do you think?

    Continue Reading

    Va. Police Officer Kicks Down Door to Save Residents in Burning Home

    Watch Wis. Police Help Turn Traffic Stop into Marriage Proposal

    Sponsored Recommendations

    Whitepaper: A New Paradigm in Digital Investigations

    July 28, 2023
    Modernize your agency’s approach to get ahead of the digital evidence challenge

    A New Paradigm in Digital Investigations

    June 6, 2023
    Modernize your agency’s approach to get ahead of the digital evidence challenge.

    Listen to Real-Time Emergency 911 Calls in the Field

    Feb. 8, 2023
    Discover advanced technology that allows officers in the field to listen to emergency calls from their vehicles in real time and immediately identify the precise location of the...

    2022 Transparency and Trust Report - Public Safety & Community Relationships

    Nov. 16, 2022
    Veritone releases its 2022 Law Enforcement Transparency and Trust Report delivering Five Key Findings of Community Sentiment on Policing

    Voice your opinion!

    To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Officer, create an account today!

    I already have an account

    Latest in Home

    Dreamstime | Officer.com News
    The Lineup Drone Image
    Command/HQ

    The Lineup Podcast: Eye in the Sky Combats Subway Surfing

    Joe Vince
    Dec. 1, 2023
    Bizuayehu Tesfaye | Las Vegas Review-Journal | TNS
    Investigations

    Bail Set at $500K for Driver Accused of Killing Nev. Troopers in Hit-and-Run

    Dec. 1, 2023
    Nicolaus Czarnecki | MediaNews Group/Boston Herald | TNS
    Command/HQ

    Boston Police Union, City Tentatively Agree to New 5-Year Contract

    Dec. 1, 2023

    Most Read

    Nev. State Troopers Killed in Hit-and-Run Incident Identified

    Keeping an Eye on Traffic with Automatic License Plate Readers

    OFFICER Media Group State of the Industry 2024 Projection Survey Summary

    Sponsored

    Listen to Real-Time Emergency 911 Calls in the Field

    Officer
    https://www.facebook.com/officercom
    https://www.linkedin.com/company/officer-com
    https://twitter.com/officercom
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Do Not Sell or Share
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    © 2023 Endeavor Business Media, LLC. All rights reserved.
    Endeavor Business Media Logo