Former Atlanta, Louisville Chief to Lead Buffalo Police Department

Erika Shields, who previously led police departments in Atlanta and Louisville, was introduced as the mayor’s choice to become Buffalo’s next police commissioner.

April 6, 2026

2 min read

What to know

Buffalo Mayor Sean Ryan announced Erika Shields, a former police chief in Atlanta and Louisville, as his choice to serve as the city’s next police commissioner.
Shields emphasized fair and equitable policing as a core principle as she prepares to lead the department, pending confirmation by the Buffalo Common Council.
She takes the role as Buffalo experiences historically low violent crime but faces challenges including contract negotiations with the police union and ongoing officer recruitment shortages.

By Justin Sondel

Source The Buffalo News, N.Y.

The onetime leader of police departments in Atlanta and Louisville has been tapped to be the next commissioner of the Buffalo Police Department.

Mayor Sean Ryan announced the appointment of Erika Shields this morning.

Shields, who grew up in Central New York, said she is happy to be working close to home and that she is excited to work with the administration, the police union and the officers to build on past successes and identify areas for improvement.

“My approach to law enforcement has been or remains one of fair and equitable policing,” Shields said. “It is not just terminology. It is essential to the backbone of every department”

Shields' appointment is subject to the confirmation of the Common Council.

The announcement came after a months-long national search led by a recruiting agency that began shortly after Ryan won the general election in November.

Ryan, in announcing the appointment, said the city received more than 40 applications from qualified candidates, which was narrowed to six finalists before Shields was chosen.

“We found a commissioner whose experience and values align with our vision, which will help us to achieve our public safety priorities, improving public safety, bolstering officer recruitment and retention and building trust with the community,” Ryan said.

Shields comes into the department at a time when violent crime numbers have continued to trend down, despite already being at historic lows. But she will face significant challenges as the city enters negotiations with the Buffalo Police Benevolent Association, whose contract expired last summer. The city, like departments across the country, is having trouble recruiting officers.

John Davidson, the police union president, said in a written statement that he looks forward to working with the new commissioner on those and other issues.

“We are hopeful that this Commissioner will prioritize solving staffing shortages and negotiating a new contract,” Davidson said.

_______________

Visit www.buffalonews.com.

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.