Ala. Town to Disband Police Department Over Insurance Coverage
What to Know
- Brookside will dissolve its police department effective Dec. 7 after town leaders said the municipality could only obtain liability insurance if it no longer operated a police force.
- Law enforcement services will shift to the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office, with officials saying coverage for residents and businesses will continue during the transition.
- The department's closure follows years of controversy over Brookside's traffic-enforcement practices and a recent legal battle between town leaders and Police Chief Marcus Sellers over the effort to disband the agency.
Brookside Mayor Mike Bryan said today that the town’s police department, once known for its lucrative speed traps on Interstate 22, would be dissolved effective Dec. 7.
The decision to eliminate the police department will be finalized during the Dec. 7 city council meeting, Bryan said. Bryan thanked members of the Brookside Police Department for their service and professionalism during the transition.
He said several department employees had already resigned to pursue other opportunities.
“On behalf of the Town Council and the residents of Brookside, I want to thank every man and woman who has worn the Brookside badge,” Bryan said.
“They answered calls at all hours, looked out for our neighbors, and served this community with dedication. Closing the Department was a difficult decision, and it was not one we made by choice. The Town can obtain liability insurance coverage only if it no longer operates a police department. Without that coverage, the Town would have no insurance at all, and we cannot responsibly ask our residents to carry that risk. This decision reflects that reality,”
Brookside will turn to the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office for law enforcement in the future.
“The Town is coordinating with the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office to ensure that law enforcement coverage for Brookside residents and businesses continues without interruption during and after the transition,” said David Lee Hubbard, Town Attorney for Brookside.
The city is advising residents to continue to call 911 for any emergency. Non-emergency questions may be directed to Brookside Town Hall.
Last month, Jefferson County Circuit Judge Monica Agee ended the restraining order she granted to Brookside Police Chief Marcus Sellers that barred the mayor and council from moving on a proposal to end police service and lay off workers.
Town leaders said the pending loss of municipal insurance by a carrier who labeled the department as a liability, is the reason to disband the department and contract with the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Department.
But the police chief said town leaders were attempting to close the department in retribution against him for questioning and reporting allegations of misappropriated money.
During a court hearing, Sellers represented himself and testified that tension with Brookside leaders began in August when he questioned spending.
“Even if they had replaced the money, the ethical part still stands,” Sellers said.
Brookside lawyers disputed Sellers’ claims, saying it was an effort to stop the town from eliminating the police department.
Brookside, a town of 1,400 north of Birmingham, was recently notified that the insurance company would end its coverage for the town in December, citing liability issues.
Policing in Brookside earned an infamous reputation. AL.com’s reporting in 2022 revealed that the town used money from traffic stops to increase its revenue by 640 percent in two years. By 2020, fines and forfeitures came to account for nearly half of the town’s revenue.
Soon after initial reporting by AL.com, the police chief at the time resigned and left town, and half of the police force quit or were forced out. The Alabama Legislature responded by passing new laws to address abuses.
Joseph D. Bryant contributed to this report.
__________
©2026 Advance Local Media LLC.
Visit al.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.




