When Evidence Is Not Real Evidence

It's at the crime scene, but is it really part of the crime scene?


With the advances in forensic science over the past decade, more and more convictions are heavily dependent on detailed and specific pieces of crime scene evidence. Hairs, fibers, threads from a piece of clothing, and of course DNA evidence, all add pieces to the puzzle of facts presented to a jury. In many cases much of this evidence is circumstantial and would not stand on its own, but as part of an overall picture it fits in.

But what if the evidence gathered is not what it appears to be? Most jigsaw puzzles are cut from fairly standard patterns. Therefore, it is possible for a piece from one puzzle to fit into a similar space in an entirely different puzzle. The pieces all fit, but the picture is not right. If this puzzle is used to convict someone, then it is possible for a person to be convicted of a crime they did not commit.

When the evidence is concocted

The crime scene investigation team combs the crime scene looking for any and all evidence that might shed light on the crime. Carpets are viewed with a variety of alternative light sources (ALS) in an attempt to illuminate any fibers or hairs on a rug that may have come from the perpetrator. However, a smart, methodical perpetrator might collect fibers from a variety of sources and leave them at the scene, causing investigators to look for a variety of things not associated with him and wasting precious time and energy in the process. A minute amount of colored plastic, like material from an asthma inhaler, might be found at a murder scene. If no one in the house was asthmatic, then it would be reasonable for investigators to assume that the perpetrator was an asthmatic and needed to use his inhaler after completing the crime. If this plastic had been taken from an empty, discarded inhaler found in the trash dumpster, it could send the investigation searching for an asthmatic when the real perp is perfectly healthy.

The trunk of a suspect's car or van is routinely screened for trace evidence. Someone who has planned their crime well in advance might collect carpet or other fibers from a variety of sources, and place them in the trunk in an attempt to confound the investigation and slow the process of obtaining reliable information from a crime lab that is already overburdened with samples. Another scenario might be where a husband kills his wife because she is having an affair with another man. He then plants fibers at the scene that he has previously removed from the lover's car or house in an attempt to point to the lover as the killer. Or maybe, he watches while the lover has a cup of coffee, then tosses the empty plastic cup in a dumpster. Retrieving the cup and planting it in the woods near his wife's shallow grave would provide investigators with the lover's fingerprints and potentially his DNA at the crime scene.

What you see or don't see

Most crimes are committed by people who act on impulse and do not plan out their crime in advance. However, many crimes are committed by serial criminals or individuals who methodically think through the various aspects of their crime so as to cover their tracks as well as possible. A notable example is Ted Kaczynski, the infamous Unabomber. Recent information released by the FBI indicates that Kaczynski used a variety of methods to elude detection and leave false evidence at these crime scenes. For eighteen years he left a trail of terror across the nation. A total of sixteen bombs were planted, killing three and injuring 23 people.

His trail of disinformation included many things to lead investigators in the wrong direction. One item was wearing shoes with the soles of smaller size shoes attached to their bottoms, leading the investigation to search for a smaller person. Kaczynski also collected human hairs from the seats of public buses and left them at bomb scenes. Pipe bombs and other types of homemade bombs can often be identified by determining the source of the pipe or end cap fragments and determining where they were sold. To evade this detection, he never bought any of his bomb material. Instead he would get materials from junkyards--materials that could not be traced. For this reason, initially Kaczynski was known to law enforcement as the "junkyard bomber."

This content continues onto the next page...
  • Enhance your experience.

    Thank you for your regular readership of and visits to Officer.com. To continue viewing content on this site, please take a few moments to fill out the form below and register on this website.

    Registration is required to help ensure your access to featured content, and to maintain control of access to content that may be sensitive in nature to law enforcement.