Excessive Use of Force--The Evil Flashlight

If you think your agency has a problem, fix it--don't scapegoat it

When I was at the sheriff's department, our sheriff got the bright idea of buying us all flashlights. This was way before the media and citizenry were all excited about people being hit with police flashlights. We're talking about a time when flashlights were seen as a tool for illumination, not a primary--or even secondary--non-lethal weapon.

Back in the day, many coppers carried what we used to refer to as "Sportsman" flashlights. These were consumer market, chrome plated lights, usually using D sized batteries, and carrying a glass lens and a standard flashlight bulb. The lens and bulb would break if you looked at the light sideways, and the tube of the flashlight's body was so thin that it would dent if it rolled off your lap onto a carpeted floor. The standard configuration seemed to be three or four cells, although I once had a partner that had what must have been a six or seven cell light.

The lights were pretty fragile, since they were intended to be put into a tackle-box or a glove compartment, and brought out once in a while to find your tent in a darkened campsite, or other such low-impact activity. Mostly they weren't intended to be banged around on a nightly basis by working cops, and they especially weren't built for hitting anyone.

Some officers taped up the barrel of their light, since the shiny chrome was pretty bad tactically, and I even knew an old-timer from a big city department (to remain nameless, although you know it as the birthplace of the automobile assembly line) who wrapped his light with solder, then taped it. He said it gave it "balance", which I think in today's parlance could be loosely translated as "weaponizing" it.

About this time we started to see the introduction into law enforcement of flashlights made of aircraft aluminum. They were called Kel-Lites®, and they were sweet! Much sturdier, and even black in color, which of course made them "tactical." No more electrical tape.

Now most of these lights were actually lighter in weight than the Sportsman variety with all the solder and tape added. However, they quickly got a reputation for being used as an impact weapon. And, even though coppers had probably always used their lights as weapons when the need arose, something about the new lights fed into the public's negative perception of the light when used in this way.

Anyway, we all had to purchase our own lights, and we used to whine about that, since we might go through several Sportsman lights a year, and the new police flashlights were kind of expensive. Our sheriff got the bright idea of buying us lights, and he rationalized that he could kill two birds with one stone, by buying us lights that were less likely to cause citizen complaints of excessive force.

This was in the days before the small, tactical lights that we have now, so "low-impact" light choices were limited. However, he persevered, and we ended up with four cell, grey and red plastic flashlights from Radio Shack™ (cost per unit was literally a dollar).

They lasted about two days, then came apart under the normal wear and tear of policing. Finally, the department went out and bought the rechargeable variety of a more standard police light.

The moral of this story is that the tools need to fit the job, and decisions should not be made based on false presumptions. And there are no shortcuts.

I thought of this saga a few weeks ago when I heard that a large west coast police agency was getting rid of their flashlights, exchanging them for a new, small, tactical variety that had been designed especially for them.

As I understand it, this came about because a couple of years ago, some officers from this department got videotaped by a news crew, allegedly striking a suspect with their flashlights. This of course led to a public outcry, and lots of media heat. The chief announced that they would do away with the flashlights, and a large flashlight manufacturer undertook to design a new, improved light, that was less likely to be used as a weapon. Two years later, the new light was ready, and announced to the world.

This content continues onto the next page...
  • Enhance your experience.

    Thank you for your regular readership of and visits to Officer.com. To continue viewing content on this site, please take a few moments to fill out the form below and register on this website.

    Registration is required to help ensure your access to featured content, and to maintain control of access to content that may be sensitive in nature to law enforcement.