Man Who Shot Florida Police Officer Killed in Gun Battle

Officials said that Jayson Colvin, who was on the run after he shot and wounded Eustis Police Capt. Gary Winheim, was killed in a gun battle with officers Thursday evening.

Orlando Sentinel
Jayson Colvin, left, and Capt. Gary Winheim
Jayson Colvin, left, and Capt. Gary Winheim
Eustis Police Department

ORLANDO, Florida — A man on the run after he was suspected of shooting a Eustis police officer was killed in a gun battle with officers Thursday evening, a department spokesman said.

“Officers located him, engaged him and he is deceased,” Eustis police Officer Lauren Brown said.

No other officers were injured in the shootout, Brown said.

Capt. Gary Winheim was airlifted to Orlando Regional Medical Center after he was shot Thursday afternoon. Winheim, who oversees criminal investigations, was reported in stable condition and his wife was by his side, according to Brown.

“He is doing great,” Brown said about Winheim. “He is expected to make a good recovery.”

Authorities identified the suspect as Jayson Colvin.

The first shooting happened about 12:15 p.m. near State Road 19 at County Road 44, authorities said.

According to police, Winheim was near a Shell gas station on duty when he reported that he heard gunshots.

Eustis police Chief Gary Calhoun said Winheim saw Colvin speed away from the gas station in a vehicle and began following him. Colvin pulled over and Winheim came up behind him and got out of his unmarked pickup truck, Calhoun said. That’s when Colvin started firing, hitting Winheim in the neck. The bullet was lodged in Winheim’s back, the chief said.

Winheim is lucky to be alive, Calhoun said.

“Another millimeter or so in another direction and it could have been a lot worse,” said Calhoun.

Winheim was in uniform but wasn’t wearing a body camera and didn’t have a dashcam in his patrol car, Brown said.

Police said a Umatilla junkyard and wooded area were also part of the crime scene investigation.

Lake County Sheriff Peyton Grinnell said a sheriff’s helicopter pilot saw Colvin hiding under a canoe near a small lake and directed SWAT team members to the area. Colvin ran away as SWAT approached, but officers saw Colvin and a gun battle ensued, Grinnell said. It’s not clear who fired first. Colvin was pronounced dead on scene.

Police from Mount Dora, Umatilla and the Florida Highway Patrol assisted in the search for Colvin. Grinnell said about 500 officers from federal, state and local law enforcement agencies participated.

The Florida Department of Law Enforcement will investigate the shooting that killed Colvin.

Colvin was a suspect in an armed robbery at the same gas station earlier this week, Brown said. It’s not clear why Colvin returned to the gas station.

Records show Colvin, 38, of Altoona, has been sentenced to state prison four times since 2000, for crimes including armed burglary, grand theft with a firearm, grand theft of a motor vehicle, fleeing law enforcement, false imprisonment, grand theft of a motor vehicle and kidnapping.

His most recent prison term was for possession of a weapon or ammunition by a felon, stemming from a 2011 arrest in Clay County. He was sentenced to seven years behind bars that December and was released in January 2018.

In March, he was arrested by Eustis police on drug charges and resisting and obstructing an officer without violence, according to the Lake County Jail. He was sentenced to one year of probation as part of a plea agreement, according to court records.

Eustis Mayor Michael Holland implored residents to refrain from posting rumors online.

“Folks, please don’t post on social media if you don’t know what you’re talking about,” Holland said. “Some of the things I’ve seen in the last hour kind of kicks you in the gut a little bit.”

He also said that “we’re a small community so anytime something like this happens it affects us very deeply.”


(Staffers Jeff Weiner and Jerry Fallstrom contributed to this report.)


©2019 The Orlando Sentinel (Orlando, Fla.)

Visit The Orlando Sentinel (Orlando, Fla.) at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

More in SWAT