A Cygnus Business Media Website            






Sponsored By:








Virginia Officer Who Shot Dachshund Fired


Posted: Saturday, July 11, 2009
Updated: July 11th, 2009 12:11 PM GMT-05:00

Most Read Stories TodayMost Read Most E-mailed Stories TodayMost E-mailed E-mail This StoryE-mail Article Print This StoryPrint Article

Story by wxii12.com

DANVILLE, Va. --

A Danville police officer who shot and killed a dachshund last Month has been fired, and the police chief called the entire incident an embarrassment to the department.

Chief Philip A. Broadfoot said officer Murrill McLean, 43, of Danville, was fired after an investigation revealed he misled a supervising officer about the details of the incident.

Police said last month that McLean, who was at a home on Berman Drive attempting to serve a warrant, shot the 11-year-old 12-pound dog, named "Killer," when it was growling and ran across the yard at him.

Broadfoot said he became suspicious of McLean's account of the incident after he visited the home himself to observe the evidence.

"My observations immediately raised questions in my mind about how the shooting actually occurred," Broadfoot said in a news release.

"The investigation determined that, while Officer McLean's fear of rabies is well-founded based on several personal life experiences, his reports of how the shooting occurred were misleading and factually inaccurate," he added.

Broadfoot said his initial decision that the shooting was justified was based on evidence McLean verbally told the supervisor.

"The supervisor accepted McLean's account without a detailed demonstration or explanation of how the shooting took place," Broadfoot said. "A proper investigation would have shown that where Officer McLean was standing during the attack would have provided him the time, distance and means necessary to consider other options before using his firearm."

Police said it is within the department's policy to shoot a dog that is presenting a threat to an officer. But the dog's owner, Tawaiin Harper, questioned the officer's actions.

"(The officer) said (he shot the dog) because he came at me. I was like, 'A little bitty dog that size?' He was like, 'I don't care what kind of dog it is.' So he said, 'I shot him,'" an emotional Harper said. "Words can't describe how he'll be missed. I did a lot of crying. I did a lot of crying about the situation just the way it happened."

Broadfoot offered an apology to Harper's family.

"I apologize to the Harper family for the loss of their pet and pledge to them that I will make changes in our operation to ensure that nothing like this happens again," he said.

"I hate to see anybody lose his job, but he made the wrong decision," Harper said.

Copyright 2009 by WXII12.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


» More Stories From Top News Stories



Share your thoughts, advice, opinions, and expertise @ Officer.com

     
Comments

Posted by vamcdenver's daddy
(07/11/09 - 03:18 PM)
vamcdenver, thank you so much for your sarcastic hyperbole. It will come in handy for the rest of us who live in and experience reality on a daily basis.

What we should really weed our are insolent poser whackers such as yourself who come to websites like this one with an agenda to spout your anti-police ramblings. Maybe you should try www.liberalprickforums.com instead.

Better yet, we can volunteer you can be first in on every call involving a dog and you can take the bite every time.



Posted by NC Officer
(07/11/09 - 05:42 PM)
vancdenver: rather than focus on the reason the officer acted the way he did, let's talk about the real problem...what brought the officer to the residence in the first place. What kind of warrant? Some BS warrant, or some AWDW? If the dog owner didn't have a warrant on him/her nor did someone at that residence, then this would probably have never happened. I do not condone lying. I'm sure that's what got this officer fired. Dumb mistakes can most of the time be excused, just don't lie!



Posted by Street Cop
(07/11/09 - 06:24 PM)
vamcdenver's daddy, Man I not even gonna attempt to say it better than you did!! I agree totally all of his posts are like this one!



Posted by G in MD
(07/11/09 - 07:28 PM)
Let me say this. I'm terrified of mice and rats, I don't know why but if a pet rat came at me, its lights out. So with that being said, you really can't measure an individuals fear of certain creatures. I feel him; but he should have man up and been acurate.



Posted by Luci in California
(07/11/09 - 07:29 PM)
It was the lying that got him fired. Yet, his killing a little daschund definitely should have caused him some grief, too.

I hate snakes AND its no secret!



Posted by Street cop
(07/11/09 - 08:53 PM)
Hey pig hater, hate me thats o.k. because everyone hates us until they need us. I know your kind big tuff strong, and all mouth until I show up! Then you cry like a little B*#$@ when your in the back of the car. Go show off for you ugly girlfriend on some other web site.
Or maybe go to Denver!



Posted by Ofcr Pete in Virginia
(07/11/09 - 09:23 PM)
Sad situation...

I dont think "the fear of dogs" something that can be weeded out prior to being hired. I've had to shoot a dog before, at Rottwieller, who broke through the a screened window and came after me. I was always taught that if it's in a mode of attack...shoot it. But a Dachshund??? Itsn't that the "hotdog" looking dog?? I might've kicked it but I don't think I would've shot and killed it.



Posted by PSC
(07/11/09 - 11:00 PM)
I serve arrest warrants daily for a living... I encounter dogs, big and small everyday.

The small dogs will bite and I have gotten bit but I would never think of shooting one.

In fact even the bigger dogs...Akita I wacked in the head with my expandable baton and that did the trick and scared it enough to leave me alone and run away.

It would take me being bit for me to fire my weapon, I do love dogs very much but I would exhaust means before I would use my firearm.

Yes, I have been bitten before and it hurts like hell but luckily I haven't had to shoot a dog.

I can understand and fully back any officer who fires on a dog who is set on attacking them but a little 11lb dog???

Buddy if your in fear of an 11lb dog or beagle running at you, you need to find another line of work.



Posted by 5.0
(07/11/09 - 11:10 PM)
Unfortunate
This is very unfortunate and very frustrating for all involved. It would be unfair for me to be bias against something I am ignorant too, as in a phobia of rabies. BUT, even being fearful of something does not warrant the lack of preclusion here, there certainly had to be other options in contrary to dispatching the animal. If he did lie to cover tracks, then his supervisor's actions were appropriate. Fellow Five O.



Posted by dpd
(07/12/09 - 12:21 AM)
Ive oc'd pits before to get them back from a fenced area Ive needed to search and it worked pretty good, im sure if i had a LARGE vicious dog chrging me i would take it out, but theres no way I would shoot a weiner dog, its not worth the paperwork or the shame in the locker room....but who knows what was going on in this dude's head, I guess it is possible for a 6 lb dog to bite through your boots and give you rabies lol









1  |   2  |   3  |  



Officer.com E-Mail Alerts
Sign Up for Free e-mail Alerts

Daily News & Features
Officer Down Alerts
Special Offers
Weekly Job Alerts