A Cygnus Business Media Website            






Sponsored By:








Former Official Accuses Baltimore PD of Corruption


Posted: Friday, July 3, 2009
Updated: July 3rd, 2009 09:45 AM GMT-05:00

Most Read Stories TodayMost Read Most E-mailed Stories TodayMost E-mailed E-mail This StoryE-mail Article Print This StoryPrint Article

Story by wbaltv.com

BALTIMORE --

The former chief of the Baltimore City Police Department Internal Disciplinary System said the department is rife with corruption and turns a blind eye to bad officers patrolling the streets.

Former Internal Affairs prosecutor Joann Branche was fired in April and is being blamed for the dismissal of at least 50 police misconduct cases.

On Thursday, she spoke publicly for the first time, taking shots at her former department.

Branche said good police officers are in the crosshairs of the department while bad ones are running willy-nilly in the city, undermining public safety.

"It is important that we have the right officers on the street and the wrong officers off the street, and it has become apparent that the police department is not serious about policing their own," said attorney Warren Brown, who is representing Branche. Joann Branche

Branche said the unit is micromanaged for political reasons and punishment is doled out based on who you know.

"There were, in fact, back-door deals in punishment. There were instances where recommendations for punishment were not followed. In fact, there were cases that should be punished that were dismissed," she said.

In response, police department spokesman Anthony Guglielmi said, "The Baltimore Police Department has a fair and prudent disciplinary system that has to be applied judiciously across the board. The department is not going to comment on personnel issues."

"The police department never affirmatively stated that she had done anything wrong," Brown said.

"I do not believe, based on my experience, that the department is capable of policing itself."

- Joann Branch

One high-profile case dismissed accused two white officers of forcing a black coworker to view racist material on the Internet. Another regarded the southwest district's flex squad in which officers were accused of raping a woman inside the police station.

"I realized the investigation had serious flaws," Branche said.

Branche contended that all of her decisions were micromanaged by Deputy Commissioner Debora Owens, who interfered with the process.

But the chief claim against Branche is an allegation that she violated officers' due process rights by backdating documents after the time expired to file charges. The department cleared Branche of one of those allegations.

Branche has not filed suit. She said she wants the department to come clean and for the mayor to dismantle Internal Affairs.

"First and foremost, I want to clear my name, but more importantly, I want to shed light on what I see as travesties in the department. I do not believe, based on my experience, that the department is capable of policing itself," she said.

Branche suggested that the mayor create an outside entity to handle police misconduct cases.

A spokesman for the mayor said she has no plans to do that.


» More Stories From Top News Stories



Share your thoughts, advice, opinions, and expertise @ Officer.com

     
Comments

Posted by Ex-Copper in Merced CA
(07/03/09 - 12:19 PM)
Baltimore P.D.
Wasn't this the same Baltimore P.D. that last week the city settled with fifteen black Officers out of court for 2 million dollars? Didn't they also allege that the Dept was selective in the handling of disciplinary cases? I think that where there is smoke there is fire!



Posted by vamcdenver
(07/03/09 - 12:26 PM)
Another argument for a state level entity that combines the functions of a civilian review board, an IA activity and a state counterpart to the USDOJ Civil Rights Division that investigates police misconduct allegations.

They need to have subpoena powers and routinely use change of venue to hear the cases.

If is a fire behind the smoke, let them find it.

If the charges are without merit, let them make that determinatlion.

If something is causing a stink, daylight is the best disinfectant.

Having a state resource like this prevents the need for federal intervention and oversight like LAPD is facing now.

It also clears the decks of local politics in the big cities.

It lifts the shadows of retaliation and undue influence in these departments. Provided by whistle blower protection acts.

Some agency IA bureaus are amateur hour, others are ineffective, or corrupt.

Other agencies have ineffective, or laughable disciplinary programs.

In Denver, you can only be punished to the level of what a previous officer received for the same offense.

No real range of discretion. In reality, since most offenses in the past merited the least possible punishment, most DPD officers receive a slap on the wrist.

Or have the action reversed on appeal later.

But while trying to keep a straight face, we can tell the public the officer was handed the appropriate level of discipline.

An agency can go to the other extreme, using IA to conduct witch hunts, running roughshod over officer's rights and ruining their reputations.

Coupled with a LEO's Bill of Rights and State oversight of IA, civil rights and review board functions, everyone is on the same page.

Instead of a sheriff's office botching an IA investigation and a metro police department turning a blind eye to officer misconduct and police corruption.



Posted by garyinindiana
(07/03/09 - 12:34 PM)
That almost makes sense. Instead of the rat squad stabbing you in the back you have big brother looking over your shoulder.



Posted by Silent in Pittsburgh
(07/04/09 - 02:46 AM)
I can't believe anyone would be against an outside organization being installed to handle these problems. There should already be one in place for every community. Why not just let the inmates watch each other in the jails? And if you are one of the good ones you have nothing to fear anyway because you should never see them. But of course a lot of cops feel you should protect your own before telling a truth that would harm them, in other words, be a "rat." But doesn't that stink in and of itself? This is why so many people these days feel the way the do about officers. They can do whatever they want and get away with it because even if you have a rightful claim, thier friends will just help them out and if they do get punished it is just a slap on the wrist.








Officer.com E-Mail Alerts
Sign Up for Free e-mail Alerts

Daily News & Features
Officer Down Alerts
Special Offers
Weekly Job Alerts