A Cygnus Business Media Website            






Sponsored By:








Guns And Planes

TSA's Performance Complicates Things


Posted: Monday, July 6, 2009
Updated: July 3rd, 2009 06:15 AM GMT-05:00

Most Read Stories TodayMost Read Most E-mailed Stories TodayMost E-mailed E-mail This StoryE-mail Article Print This StoryPrint Article

JOHN WILLS
Training Contributor


I've been retired for five years; I work for a private company as a LE trainer. I'm required to bring weapons with me to the job, most of which I have to travel to by airplane. While I was still an FBI Agent I never had any problem carrying a weapon when I traveled by air; I simply presented my credentials at the security checkpoint and then made my way to the gate. That was then, this is now.

Now, I'm just a member of the herd which is no big deal. I have no problem submitting to whatever protocol has been established to board an airplane. Having been a cop and an agent all of my adult life, I'm a law and order guy. I like it when there are rules in place to guide people and safeguard things like travel. What I don't like is when the rules are ambiguous and arbitrary... when they can be interpreted differently by individuals in the same agency. Let me explain.

I was returning home from a job last week and was at an airport in the South. I had a couple of Glock pistols with me that I declared to the ticket agent at check-in. This is where the absurdity of the TSA regulations concerning firearms in checked baggage begins. The ticket agent told me that I'd needed to show her the weapons. No problem. I opened my luggage, took out the hard case with a padlock securing it and unlocked it. She told me that I had to show her that they were both unloaded - I complied by locking the slides to the rear and showing her the empty chambers and empty magazines. I re-secured the weapons and lock, signed the short form, and then she taped a bright orange sticker on top of the case that read, FIREARMS UNLOADED.

This same airline at a different airport several weeks ago simply asked me if the weapons were unloaded - to which I replied, yes - and then had me fill out a form. She never asked to see the weapons; she simply threw the declaration inside my suitcase and sent it on its way. On other occasions, I have had to wait while a TSA officer was summoned to take me aside to check my weapons. Almost all of them have no clue about firearms - how they work, nomenclature, etc., yet they are sent to check people who transport them in luggage. Most never handle the weapons; they simply use two fingers to feel the Styrofoam padding inside of the case. What they're checking for I'm uncertain of, yet they go out of their way not to touch the guns. I carry handguns, rifles, and Tasers. TSA agents have never physically touched them to ensure they were unloaded. On occasion, especially in New York, they will summon a cop assigned to the airport to conduct the inspection. They will do a safety check, question you as to why you're carrying the guns, and then send you on your way.

Last week's episode was a bit much for me. I checked in at the ticket counter and declared that I had two pistols, as I described above, then went through the controlled stampede at the security checkpoint. (That's another story for later, having been cleared twice even though I had a knife in my possession). As I'm heading for my gate, and my flight departure window is closing, I am summoned back to the ticket counter via the public address system.

I make my way back where I am met by a uniformed TSA officer. Incidentally, TSA has recently changed their uniform to resemble a police uniform - dark blue shirts and gold badges - I'm not sure why they did that but I hope that it wasn't to give the impression that they are cops - they're not. The officer advises me that my weapon is not secure in the case. I reply that I've been through at least 100 check-ins using that same case and lock and have never had anyone tell me that. I glance down at my watch and see that my flight window is closing quickly, especially if I have to go through the checkpoint again. He doesn't want to hear it. I show him my retired LEO ID; I may as well have shown him a picture of last year's family reunion for all the impact that it made.

So I ask him, "What must I do to satisfy your needs?" He replies, "Get another lock." He tells me while pointing to a little shop across the lobby that I can buy a lock there. I walk over and search the entire store - no locks. I ask the cashier if she sells locks. No. I walk back to the TSA officer and advise him that the store doesn't sell locks. End of story? No. He goes behind ticket counter, talks to another TSA officer, and sends him to the same store to see if they sell locks. I assume the guy thinks that I'm lying to him, even after I've shown him that I'm a retired cop.

Several minutes later, the second TSA guy saunters back and tells the first guy that the store doesn't sell locks. The pair confers privately and the second guy ambles off in a different direction this time. I ask the first TSA guy what's happening and he tells me that he's checking a different store across the terminal. He says that they sell gun cases with locks starting at $75.00. I look down at my watch - time is running out, and so is my patience. I try to explain my situation to him. It's Friday night, I'm on the second to the last flight out for the day. I need to get home tonight because my grandson has a hockey game tomorrow. He tells me that he can't let the guns on like that; what if someone was able to pry open the case and take them?

The absurdity hits me like a frying pan in the face. My luggage is soft side. Thanks to TSA, the only acceptable locks are those that TSA approves - ones that are so small and flimsy that they can be pried open by hand. Better yet, the baggage handlers know how to open luggage by simply using a pen to compromise the zippers. Once inside the luggage, all they need to see is my gun case with the bright orange sticker taped on top that says FIREARMS UNLOADED. Then they just take the whole darn case. The TSA guy is not swayed by my rationale.

TSA guy number two shuffles back and tells number one that there are indeed cases for sale with locks at whatever store he was at. But to my surprise, TSA guy one tells me that he doesn't want to see me get stuck for seventy five bucks. He goes in the back and miraculously comes up with a solution. He has decided to use a discarded TSA lock that he puts on my case. He tells me that he doesn't have the combination to it, but that I can cut it off when I get home (when I got home I yanked it apart by hand). I thank him and ask him to escort me around the security checkpoint since I now am in danger of missing my flight. He declines, telling me that I have to go through it again. I end up being the last one to board, but I do make the flight.

The thrust of this article isn't to chronicle my travails during that experience, but rather to illustrate my frustration with TSA's lack of uniformity and protocol. Each airport and airline has different guidelines for weapons in checked baggage. Moreover, the methodology for discerning whether the gun is loaded or not is ludicrous. The Israelis would look at these inspections and be appalled. They simply serve no purpose as they exist, except as a function for covering someone's backside if something goes sideways.

Air travel security isn't to be taken lightly. I would welcome strict new standards that would be conducted by people who are well trained and knowledgeable about firearms. What happens now at the nation's airports is unacceptable.

Stay safe brothers and sisters!




Web Links:

John M. Wills spent 33 years in law enforcement as a Chicago Police Officer and FBI Special Agent (Ret). He is a Freelance Writer and Speaker whose book, Chicago Warriors Midnight Battles in the Windy City, is now available online at Amazon and Barnes & Noble. Contact John through his website: www.johnmwills.com.

» More Stories From Police Life



Share your thoughts, advice, opinions, and expertise @ Officer.com

     
Comments

Posted by John Kinane,ESFLEA VP Operations in Rochester NY
(07/06/09 - 10:03 AM)
TSA Security
Unfortunately TSA has been a disaster since its inception. The original plan was to create a uniformed TSA Police force consisting of trained federal law enforcement officers, but instead reverted to the cheaper solution of hiring private security rent a cops, most of who performed the same duties pre TSA,only now at a higher rate of pay. Our organization, the Emerald Society of the Federal Law Enforcement Agencies (www.esflea.org) has for many years attempted to change this preposterous system, but has fallen on deaf ears of the legislature.



Posted by Alexander in Texas
(07/06/09 - 01:28 PM)
The TSA is a joke. They are almost completely ineffective at protecting airflight.

You had better believe that they changed the uniform to dark blue to appear to be LEOs. There are a LOTS of "Security Consulting Firms" telling them to do exactly that, for the sole purpose of riding piggy back on LE legal authority. Some of them even write on this site occasionally. They suggest all kinds of stuff, even wearing stupid badges that say "OFFICER" or "SECURITY ENFORCEMENT". In Texas, a lot of these firms are geting shut down because of the law prohibiting impersonating a LEO. But the "consultants" are stil out there.

Sorry for your bother with traveling. I understand it is a pain. TSA has become nothing but a jobs program for people who neither understand security, nor do they want to. The last thing TSA does is actually protect the plane.

I won't go into them here, for obvious reasons, but there are huge glaring holes in airport security. Neither the FAA, nor the airlines want to address them, but making the TSA harrass travelers makes the appearance of providing security. But it's just an appearance.




Posted by John
(07/06/09 - 01:36 PM)
I������ve found rules change from airport to airport, airline to airline. My (least) favorite story is the first time I was told to wait at ������Special Handling������ for my luggage only to later have my wife find it on the carrousel after everyone else picked up their bags and marked, ������HAND DELIVER-FIREARM������ in orange sticker. I waited for the bag at the carrousel opening the next flight and sure enough, it was ������hand delivered������ the same way.



Posted by John in Tennessee
(07/06/09 - 01:51 PM)
Unfortunately our country is run by people with money and political influence! By that I mean, we put rules and regulations in place and along comes somebody who "has money or political influence" and BAM!, something that inconvenienced them gets changed.

I used to work for TSA and saw this on a daily basis. A rule was in place for everybody to remove their shoes. The next week it was changed, because it bothered somebody.

If our powers that be were truly concerned about the safety of our flying public, they would tell the inconvenienced politicians or millionaires to go lay down.

These people should have to go live in a place like Israel for a while where they take their safety seriously, then they would realize how well we have it.



Posted by The Shamus
(07/06/09 - 04:48 PM)
James in Tucson you should file a complaint for that treatment. Maybe nothing will happen but you never know.

Transportation Security Administration
Office of Civil Rights and Liberties (TSA-6)
External Compliance Division
601 S. 12th Street
Arlington, VA 22202

TSA is a total nightmare in every way. I have to deal with them all the time and it is incredible.



Posted by Al in Miami, Fl.
(07/06/09 - 05:14 PM)
As a recently retired P.O. I feel your pain. I'm a 34 year veteran P.O. who has flown armed on and off duty out of Miami to other large cities. What a hassel, I don't think I've ever done the same proceedure twice. Even within the same airlines I had to jump through different hoops at different cities. As for TSA what a joke. I've wanted to strangle some of those fools but sanity prevailed. I use to love flying but got to hate it just because of the hassels at the airport.



Posted by Al in Miami, Fl.
(07/06/09 - 05:15 PM)
As a recently retired P.O. I feel your pain. I'm a 34 year veteran P.O. who has flown armed on and off duty out of Miami to other large cities. What a hassel, I don't think I've ever done the same proceedure twice. Even within the same airlines I had to jump through different hoops at different cities. As for TSA what a joke. I've wanted to strangle some of those fools but sanity prevailed. I use to love flying but got to hate it just because of the hassels at the airport.



Posted by 146 in KC
(07/06/09 - 05:21 PM)
Thanks for all this great information. I've decided I'm just going to stay home. Good article John Wills.



Posted by J. in Irmo, SC
(07/06/09 - 06:04 PM)
TSA and airport security.
I don't know why public safety officers can't get 'status' clearance for airplane flights and border crossings. If you want to speed things up, make it a quicker process for those that already have clearance in their home jurisdiction. Just another good reason to utilize HR218 and drive.



Posted by Rod Bernsen in CO
(07/06/09 - 06:16 PM)
TSA Kudos
I empathize with our retired FBI brother; the TSA really does have a lot of room for improvement.
However, in December 2008, I was rushing to catch a flight home as my adult son was in the hospital and could have died at any moment. I showed my retired LAPD ID at the first check point and was allowed to jump the line. When I got to the screening area-- same problem and same solution. A TSA Supervisor put me at the head of the line and I made my flight home.
With all the complaints, some justified and others not, I think it important to give an "atta-boy" when well deserved.
Rod Bernsen
Sergeant, LAPD Retired









1  |   2  |   3  |  



Officer.com E-Mail Alerts
Sign Up for Free e-mail Alerts

Daily News & Features
Officer Down Alerts
Special Offers
Weekly Job Alerts