Mentoring…

Frank Borelli
Editor-in-Chief
Officer.com

Mentor:

  1. A wise and trusted counselor or teacher.
  2. To serve as a trusted counselor or teacher.

Welcome to April; the beginning of spring – a time for new growth from what has been dormant since fall. Pardon the reach, but isn’t this something new growing from that which is old? Last year’s maturity being passed into this year’s youth? Throughout the ages this has been a path of education, wisdom – and to some extent – likes and dislikes. Yet here I sit, as a man who has served in one uniform or another for more than 25 years now, and as I look back there are only one or two mentors I remember having. Why is that?

Here’s what I think: I think that the days where our society in general recognizes the value in mentoring, coaching, or offering guidance are waning. Why would that be? I’m not entirely sure, but I am sure that it’s not a good thing. Think back…

There have been and are professions that require apprenticeship. Electricians, air conditioning / heating, brick masons, stone masons… they all require apprenticeship. The priesthood and law enforcement require apprenticeship, but under different names. I went to a private Catholic high school run by the Trinitarians. Brothers had made a commitment but weren’t ordained yet (they weren’t “Fathers”). Does that make them apprentices of sorts? I believe so. Many agencies have a cadet program, and even those that don’t usually have a Field Training Officer program. Such programs require new or not-yet officers to work under the tutelage of an experienced officer. Is this not apprenticeship?

Here’s the kicker for me – a light bulb moment if you will: My sons grow under my tutelage; my direction. They learn values, belief structure, right and wrong, and judgment (God help them) under my guidance. Is this not apprenticeship? Are they not learning how to become men?

I find it humorous that my youngest son – at the grand old age of ten – loves Star Wars and the idea of Jedi Knights, but he absolutely doesn’t like it if I call him “padawan” (another name for the student or apprentice Jedi Knight in Star Wars). He adores learning, but doesn’t like to admit that he doesn’t know everything. Maybe this is a result of his age. Maybe it’s an outlook he’s learned for me (I already asked for God to help him above, remember?). Maybe it’s representative of an outlook shared by many and if it is a societal outlook, I believe it may be denying us potentially great training and wisdom.

When I look around at the veteran officers I know, it occurs to me that many of them are not offering any training or wisdom. The Field Training Officers I know are usually five to seven year veteran officers, and I wonder, “Why them?” Why not the twelve to fifteen year Sergeant? Obviously there are good reasons for not assigning your Sergeants rookies to train. By the same token, once that rookie has been cut loose and is working on his own, he still accepts and needs guidance from his Sergeant. In that role, the Sergeant is a mentor.

I was lucky to have a couple growing up. My Uncle Don was a great mentor – and he took that responsibility seriously. I had a cousin that I considered a mentor, but as I look back now I realize that he never was. Everything he taught me was ultimately about selfish desires and how to skirt the rules. Was my Drill Sergeant a mentor? Yes and no. Was my counselor in the police academy a mentor? Absolutely yes, and he did a good job (thanks Dave!). I knew a couple other veteran officers in the early years of my career and one or two of them tried to serve as mentors, albeit not intentionally and only on an irregular basis at best.

As I look back at my past, and consider my own sons today, I realize that those our society seems to sometimes cast aside have an awful lot of knowledge and experience to offer, and quite often all they want in return is an attentive ear. Retired officers can serve as fantastic mentors. Military service veterans have learned some of life’s harshest lessons – and they are more than willing to share them if we would just listen. Often those lessons don’t strictly apply only to military life or missions. In fact, three of the best lessons I ever learned from my military experience carry over to virtually every facet of life. They are:

  • Just don’t quit.
  • You don’t have to like it; you just have to do it.
  • Focus on the mission; ignore the distractions.

Odd that I didn’t have a mentor reinforcing those rules of living for me during my time as a Military Policeman in the regular Army. In fact, I heard those words most from my Sergeant in the Maryland Army National Guard in a Light Infantry unit – when I was past thirty years old.

What’s the point of this rambling rant? MENTOR. YOU have something to offer your children, nieces, nephews, coworkers, rookies, etc. BE MENTORED. You have something to learn from your parents, aunts, uncles, grandparents, and other officers - both those more and less experienced than you are. LEARN from them.

What do you think?

 

Current Responses "Mentoring…"

  1. Frank; while I agree with you and most of your post, I think there is a fundamental difference between “mentoring” and “parenting”. I agree that they are very close and there are obvious similarities.
    In my life we have had many conversations about this exact topic and where the problem lies, or more importantly when the problem begins. Yes, you should be a mentor to your children. But I see parenting as a much larger undertaking, of which being a mentor is only a portion of the task at hand. As you mention above, society has gone away from this being important. I don’t think we would be talking about the value of being a mentor to others if there was not such a massive problem (in my opinion) with parenting in general. There seems to be little discipline offered by parents (most). There seems to be little “life direction” offered by parents. The problems for me start with the erosion of the family. Kids have less people to look up to, or less heroes, or less “mentors”, - so then they do not have the ability/skills/experience to be a positive influence on anyone themselves later in life. This starts a downward cycle that is very hard to come out of…..


    Political Disgust

  2. Susan

    I think mentoring is an excellent way to bring up the next generation of anyone in any profession. Unfortunately, it seems that mentoring has fallen by the wayside in policing due to the competitive nature of agencies.
    Viewing it in the most unbiased way I can, I see people who are fearful of the newer, younger person replacing them, as in “threat,” instead of viewing them as their replacement when they choose to retire or simply leave.
    Nobody is irreplaceable and if those with experience share their knowledge and experience, they could possibly leave a legacy behind with the newer, younger person.
    I believe it is our duty to share our knowledge and experience and hope that the person we are teaching will take it and do much better then we did.

  3. Frank, it’s extremely important in society both in the workforce and at home. Whether it’s a man and his sons or a woman and her daughters, it is the way that nature in general teaches the next generation what is acceptable and what is not. Pass it on–all of us are role models; someone is always watching and modeling our behavior both good and bad.

Leave a Comment